When a sukkah is on an elephant

By Jessica Russak-Hoffman

The Talmud, in tractate Sukkah, discusses constructing a sukkah on an elephant. The Biblical Museum of Natural History in Israel made it happen.

“It’s hard to avoid talking about the elephant in the room, which is literally the elephant in the room,” said Rabbi Natan Slifkin, the museum director known as the “zoo rabbi.”

The life-size replica of an African elephant is on regular display in the museum and typically illustrates the Talmudic notion of the elephant being “one of the wonders of creation.” The elephant has also been dressed as a “Seleucid war elephant doing battle with the Maccabees,” says Slifkin.

The Talmud discusses both putting the sukkah atop an elephant and using the animal as one of the sukkah walls.

“We did both,” Slifkin said. “It was relatively straightforward for us to build one in the museum, since our elephant is not a living animal.”

The Talmud also mentions constructing a sukkah on a camel.

“You can build a much better sukkah on an elephant, with its broad back, than on a camel,” Slifkin observed.

“Why would the Mishnah mention a camel? Historically, camels were a common form of transport in the land of Israel, and people sometimes mounted framed, roofed passenger structures on top of them.

“It was thus natural to discuss whether it would be possible to create a sukkah in such a way,” Slifkin said.

The average person was likelier to have a horse, donkey or cow than an elephant, but the large animal was also used in the discussion to illustrate what would happen if the animal died or collapsed, according to Slifkin.

“It would still leave you with something big enough to use as a sukkah wall.”