When I was in my early twenties I gashed my forehead on a Friday night and ended up in the emergency room on the Friday night of a Thanksgiving weekend. It being Shabbat plus Thanksgiving, somehow I was not treated within the limited window of time necessary to receive stitches. I was bandaged up, but not in a way believed to be an optimal medical manner that would leave my forehead smooth with no mark of the incident.
Later, I found my way to the best pharmacy in New York City, replete with the best lotions and potions for, at a minimum, camouflaging scars and with the hopes of the best results prevailing over time, erasing them completely.
I asked a particular pharmacist for help, beginning to tell him my story when, feeling a sense of shame, I noticed his face was horribly scarred around his left eye.
I then stopped myself, and I dont remember what I said next, but somehow, the next thing I knew we were engaged in a personal conversation. I remember him asking me why I so badly wanted to treat the scar in a way that would erase it, thereby erasing the memory of the event that caused it? He went on to confide in me about the scars on his face.
When he was a young child, he told me, he was in a car accident with his dad. He survived. His dad did not. To him, the scars on his face are his link and connection to his dad, and all that transpired in his life since that terrible day, he explained. Why would he want to erase that? It was a part of his life; his father is with him within these scars. They were a part of who he was and he did not want to lose pieces of who he was.
I felt humbled.
In this weeks Torah portion, Vayishlach, we read about one of the most mysterious encounters in Tanach (Hebrew Bible). On the banks of the Yabok river, a body of water that literally reflects our face back at us, reflects who we see, Jacob wrestles with the ish, literally man, but often loosely translated as angel. What marks the conclusion of this all night struggle between Jacob and his opponent, whether he is the guardian angel of Esau or an inner part of Jacob himself, is Jacob being touched by this mysterious force, exacting a wound at his hip.
After this intense, mysterious struggle of Jacob he is forever changed and different marked by his displaced hip. For the rest of Jacobs life he will always carry the scar of this night with him. From here on Jacob lives crippled by this struggle; his body, as his life, is permanently altered.
According to the Midrash, Jacob and Esau were already struggling from within their mother Rebeccas womb. In their exit from the womb and emergence into this world, they were quite literally born wrestling. In fact, Jacob is named for it, Yaakov from the root of the word heel, for he emerges into this world grabbing onto his twin Esaus heel.
Once again, in this weeks narrative, if we go with the interpretation that the mysterious force Jacob is wrestling is indeed Esaus guardian angel we see Jacob attaching himself, grabbing on, resisting letting go yet again. This time Jacob, undefeated, refuses to let go, pleading for a closing benediction from the opponent he has succeeded in vanquishing.
The response to this request?
A question.
What is your name?
And very simply Jacob responds: Jacob.
Well, obviously, you might think. But the last time Jacob is asked this very same, obvious question, also at a time of receiving a blessing, it was his own father, Isaac, who asked. Then, it was not all that obvious. As we know, Jacob responded to Isaac identifying himself as his twin Esau, clouding his true identity.
As per the song in Les Mis who am I this seems to be the crux of the struggle for Jacob. Last time he was asked this question Jacob did not say who he was, even if for spiritual reasons that are beyond us it was the right decision for Jacob at the time. But to verbalize and deceive your own father with your twins identity, and then, after years of heartache and hostility, fear and separation, anticipating a reunion with the very brother whose blessing, name and identity you usurped there is no way that does not haunt someone. Especially someone as great and noble as Jacob our forefather, whose signature quality is his integrity.
Who am I? Yes. Jacob needs to decide who he is. For he has lived out the blessing of Esau, becoming a prosperous businessman enveloped by an abundance of riches.
Two brothers. Years of separation. All the while Jacob fearing for his life as a consequence of a deed that caused the wrath of one brother to want to kill the other. Jacob is about to be reunited with his brother Esau. It is the night before they are about to meet. There was an intimacy of brotherhood between them once, as they lived together in one home, under one roof, with their parents. Then everything was destroyed. And now is a chance to reconcile or, at the very least, to try to heal that wound. Jacob is struggling with the spirit of Esau, and with himself. They are one and the same.
Jacob invites this struggle. He sends his family ahead and remains behind, alone. His struggles with Laban are behind him now. His impending meeting with his brother lies ahead. At the heart of this encounter lies Jacobs honest self-reflection about brotherly hate and alienation, about G-d and his own destiny in this world. As Jacob says at the end, it is in this place that he saw G-d face-to-face. Inner struggle and honesty, desire for reconciliation this is encountering G-d. This is when we can actually see the face of G-d.
After years of being on the run, after many trials and tribulations since the day Jacob fled the wrath of his brother Esau, and after a struggle that lasts the night, Jacob is seeking a blessing. And what does he receive? A new name. And he said, not Jacob should anymore be called thy name, but Israel.
Jacobs birth name, Yaakov, is intrinsically linked to Esaus, for Jacob is named for grabbing onto his twin Esaus heel. Then Jacob goes on to identify himself as Esau and to receive and live out Esaus blessing.
Now on this nocturnal wrestle for his identity, a night of struggle and remorse for the past, Jacob emerges with a new name. Now Jacob is conferred with the name, Yisrael, Israel. There is a certain distance or break from his previous, close link to Esau. Now Jacob is Yisrael. Yisrael within Yaakov. Almost a twin within a twin.
But this transformation within Jacob can only begin to develop and arise after he owns, acknowledges and identifies himself as Yaakov pure and simple. The Yaakov who is separate from Esau, who is not Esau, and yet, inextricably intertwined with Esau.
I see a brother, a twin, a Yaakov who so badly wants to attach himself, literally, to the heel of his brother. And yet, his test lies in embracing himself and perhaps even painfully accepting a certain detachment he must undergo from his brother.
Poignantly, here again, in the struggle in the night, it is Jacob grabbing onto Esau, so to speak, not wanting to let go. Or, at least, not without some kind of reconciliation.
In light of this, perhaps this night of struggle was a night of remorse for the course his life had taken, away from his twin, and for the pain of realizing that he and Esau dont go together; ultimately, cannot be together.
For after their unexpected, touching meeting, when Esau weeps at seeing Jacob, and kisses him, and Jacob tells Esau that seeing him is like seeing G-d, and despite Esau reaching out for Jacob and asking him to journey together, Jacob declines the invitation and goes with his family in a different direction.
Somewhere inside of him, it is a lonely departure for Jacob, I think.
And Jacob walks away wounded. Wounded from his contribution to this dynamic between him and Esau. Wounded by the truth of the need for their separation. Wounded with the scars that will remain with him of leaving behind Yaakov-Esau, the bond of his twinship, and transitioning to becoming Israel.
Wounded, but undefeated. Wounded by an attachment to a brother and scarred by the honesty of a struggle.
The sun rose as he left Penuel. And he was limping . . .


