I USED to laugh, too, when people would suggest that the US might someday put the UN above its own national interests.
I used to laugh, too, during the 2008 presidential campaign when some suggested that Barack Obama would attenuate Americas status in the world by elevating the status of the world.
Paranoid, I thought.
Now I look at Syria and wonder.
Not only about the primacy of America, but about the welfare of the world.
Surely, the world includes civilians.
Specifically, the 15,000 civilians killed in cold blood by the Assad regime in the last 15 months.
Surely, that qualifies, if nothing else, as a humanitarian crisis.
And yet, what has the US done?
Let me rephrase and reduce that question: What have we even tried to do?
Outside the halls of the UN, the answer is: virtually nothing.
No food aid.
No sequestered safety zones for the innocent.
Not to mention, no no-fly zones, no military aid to rebels, no direct attacks on Assad.
Instead, the US provides rebels with coordination of weapons acquisition, communications and intelligence gathering whatever they may be, and obviously to no good effect.
What the US has really done is to allow China and Russia to tie our hands at the UN.
As if the US needs the sanction of the UN to act.
As if, while we wait for the UN, the killing stops.
Thats what its come down to.
If the UN is with us, we act.
If not, not.
At least on Syria.
Thats mighty close to putting international sovereignty above our own.
I say, carefully, international sovereignty.
Not international interests.
Because it is a clear, compelling, international interest to stop the mass killing of civilians in Syria.
And Obama expects us to regard as credible his claim that no option is off the table vis-a-vis Iran?
When President Bill Clinton led a NATO bombing campaign to save lives in Kosovo, he did not seek UN approval first.
When President Franklin D. Roosevelt did not bomb the rail lines to Auschwitz, he hid behind what we now know was the totally false claim that such a bombing campaign would detract from the successful prosecution of the war against the Nazis.
But FDR did act vigorously against the Nazis.
Without the UN.
Because there was no UN.
Which brings us to the self-defeating circular reasoning here: The UN was founded to preserve the peace, and thats why we must support the UN.
Uh, even when the UN does not preserve the peace?
As in Syria today?
THERE is a bigger issue: Obama seems to operate with no larger vision for the Middle East. Yes, Israel should stop building settlements. Yes, the military in Egypt should get along with the Muslim Brotherhood in Egypt. Yes, the US should remain a staunch ally of Saudi Arabia.
Do you see a vision here? I see only isolated pieces.
Punctuated by feckless pleas to Bashar Assad to, please, pretty please, leave office.
How can this be regarded as serious, let alone successful, diplomacy?
A brutal dictator, firmly ensconced in power, will leave just because other nations ask him to?
Whats the plan? Suppose Assad did leave, then what?
Suppose China and Russia actually changed their minds and stopped backing Assad, then what?
No end game is articulated by the Obama administration. No plan, no vision.
This is disheartening not only because of the excessive deference to the UN with dire humanitarian implications, enumerated above but because the instability in Syria presents a golden opportunity to weaken Syrias strongest ally: Iran.
But no. What Russia and China say at the UN is more important than Americas national interest to curb Irans power.
Meanwhile, the needless deaths and suffering in Syria multiply.
And Israel seems to pay less attention to the Obama administrations objections to its policies on the West Bank. Again, let us say that Israel did hearken to Obama and did cease all settlement building on the West Bank, then what?
Whats the plan?
Obama seems to have none. The idea that the Palestinians would rush to the table if Israel ceased all settlement activity on the West Bank is erroneous, for Israel did cease all settlement activity on the West Bank for 10 months (2009-2010) and the Palestinians did not come to the table.
Meanwhile, with no apparent plan for the Middle East other than the UN Security Council, which is paralyzed, the killing in Syria continues.
Our response, our plan, seems to be handwringing.
Copyright © 2012 by the Intermountain Jewish News


