Intermountain Jewish News

Banner
Wednesday,
Jul 30th
Home News Israel Did Israel beat an innocent, or a rioter?

Did Israel beat an innocent, or a rioter?

E-mail Print PDF

Tariq Abu Khdeir flanked by Israeli police officerJERUSALEM — For Israelis, the enduring image of the past few weeks may be the montage of the three Israeli teens murdered last month after being abducted from a hitchhiking post in the West Bank.

But another image has emerged in the last few days that is unlikely to garner much sympathy for Israel: a minute-long video in which a Palestinian-American teenager is beaten by two Israeli border policemen.

One officer is seen pinning Tariq Abu Khdeir to the ground while the other pummels the 15-year-old with his fists and kicks to his head.

After the incident, photos of the boy’s bloody face, including black eyes and a severely swollen lip, rocketed around the globe.

It was but one episode in a gruesome few days that saw Tariq’s cousin, Mohammed Abu Khdeir, burned to death apparently by Jewish terrorists, Gaza rocket crews fire scores of missiles into Israel and the Israeli army respond with an expanded bombing operation of targets in the Gaza Strip.

Amid the escalation of violence, Tariq’s beating received even wider attention because it was captured on video and because he is a US citizen from Tampa, Fla. And the beating was doled out not by extremists but by Israeli authorities — Border Police wearing the green uniforms of the Israel Defense Forces.

“We are profoundly troubled by reports that he was severely beaten while in police custody and strongly condemn any excessive use of force,” State Department spokeswoman Jen Psaki said in a statement.

“We are calling for a speedy, transparent and credible investigation and full accountability for any excessive use of force.”

Israeli police have accused Tariq of rioting and attacking officers. The teen and his family say he was observing Palestinian protests of the killing of his cousin but was not participating in rioting.

“I was just watching,” Tariq told ABC News. When the Israeli police set upon him, he said, “I was blown. I was like, why is this all happening? Why would you attack me like that? At least try to tell me why would you do that to me if I didn’t do anything to you.”

THIS is not the first time that video footage has emerged that fueled accusations against Israeli soldiers or police of excessive use of force.

In mid-May, Israeli authorities faced questions after videos surfaced showing two Palestinian teenagers being shot to death while seemingly idle. The incident took place outside Ofer Prison in the West Bank, where Palestinians marking Nakba Day, the anniversary of the “catastrophe” of Israel’s birth, clashed with Israeli authorities during protests that at times turned violent.

Palestinians said no rocks were being thrown at the time that Muhammad Abu Thahr, 15, and Nadim Nuwara, 17, were shot with live ammunition.

Israeli authorities at first said only rubber bullets were used during the clashes, then suggested that the video footage may have been doctored.

An autopsy conducted on Nuwara’s body showed that live fire had been used, according to Israeli media reports.

For the time being, Tariq’s case is receiving plenty of media attention in the US. Tariq and his parents have given interviews to CNN, ABC News, the Washington Post and a host of other outlets.

The Council of American-Islamic Relations in Florida has taken up the cause, calling for Tariq’s speedy release and portraying him as a regular American kid who likes playing soccer and video games.

“Tariq, as you know, is a young American boy who last week on Thursday was brutally attacked on his family land in Palestine where Israeli police officers in uniform brutally shackled his hands and proceeded to brutally, brutally attack him and beat him,” Hassan Shibly, an attorney for the council, said this week at a Florida news conference.

Among Jewish groups, the incident hasn’t prompted much comment. While Jewish organizations across the political and religious spectrum condemned the killing last week of Mohammed Abu Khdeir once Jews were arrested for abducting him and burning him to death, they have hardly remarked on Tariq’s beating.

One exception was J Street, which called it a “vicious beating.”

A spokesman for the ADL told JTA that it was withholding judgment for now.

“Tariq Abu Khdeir was arrested for participating in a violent demonstration against Israeli authorities, and he remains under house arrest. The circumstances of his detention are currently under investigation,” the spokesman said.

“We will await the outcome of that investigation before drawing any conclusion about his alleged treatment.”

 

IJN e-Edition

This is only a taste! Get full access to the IJN via our e-Edition, only $14.04 for IJN Print subscribers.

E-Edition subscribers get access to a complete digital replica of the IJN, which includes all special sections.

Get the IJN's free newsletter!

Shabbat Times

JTA News

Op-Ed: Learning to argue on Tisha b’Av

Daniel Treiman We can have passionate disagreements without descending into hatred, Yehudah Mirsky writes. ... [Link]

Israel, U.S. deny account of tense Obama-Netanyahu call

Ron Kampeas U.S. and Israeli officials sharply denied an account of a tense conversation between President Obama and Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu. ... [Link]

Amid uncertainty of an open-ended war, U.S.-Israel tensions rise

Ron Kampeas Rapidly changing events on the ground in the Israel-Hamas war in Gaza are accompanied by volatility in the U.S.-Israel relationship. ... [Link]

France extradites Brussels Jewish museum shooting suspect

Marcy Oster The Frenchman suspected of killing four people at the Jewish Museum of Belgium was extradited by France to Belgium. ... [Link]

4 videos on the Gaza war that have pro-Israel viewers cheering

Uriel Heilman Amid the fighting in Gaza and Israel, video clips of Joan Rivers, Howard Stern, Ron Dermer and Hillel Neuer are cheering the pro-Israel crowd. ... [Link]

U.K. supermarket chain to stop carrying West Bank products

Anthony Weiss The largest supermarket chain in the United Kingdom has announced that it will cease to sell products sourced in the West Bank by September. ... [Link]

Poll: Less than 4 percent of Israeli Jews believe firepower on Gaza excessive

Marcy Oster Less than 4 percent of Israeli Jews believe the Israel Defense Forces has used excessive firepower in Gaza, an Israeli survey found. ... [Link]

In U.S., Gaza conflict reverberates on air and in the streets

Uriel Heilman American supporters and critics of Israel are battling it out over the Gaza conflict — with commentary, slogans, demonstrations and some notable rants by Joan Rivers and Howard Stern. ... [Link]

Intermountain Jewish News • 1177 Grant Street • Denver, CO 80203 • 303 861 2234 • FAX 303 832 6942
email@ijn.com • larry@ijn.com • lori@ijn.com