Intermountain Jewish News

Nov 26th

Yazidi. Let it not be another genocide.

E-mail Print PDF

The US is doing the right thing in trying to stop the brutal mass murder of the Yazidi by ISIL. The ‘take-home’ message is that ISIL is far from alone.

The past week in ever-bloody Iraq has given us — to use a popular catch-phrase — a number of teachable moments.

On the most basic level, we have learned something of the Yazidi, an obscure population whom, it’s safe to say, very few Westerners knew anything about until very recently.

Descended from the Kurdish people with a religion that draws from Islam, Christianity, Zoroastrianism and even Judaism, tens of thousands of them are, as of press time, stranded on a remote mountaintop in the Kurdistan region, surrounded by ISIL (Islamic State of Iraq and Levan, also known as ISIS, Islamic State of Iraq and Syria) terrorists who consider them heretics. The death-peddlers of ISIL have already murdered a great many Yazidi and would very much like to finish the job.

Which provides another teachable moment, one which we probably don’t really need after the litany of Islamist atrocities in recent years, but which remains vitally important considering the gravity of the big picture.

That Islamists hate and wish to kill everybody but themselves is something they have demonstrated exceedingly well since 9/11, but the level of genocide aspired to by ISIL concerning the Yazidi demonstrates the level of sheer brutality to which they are willing to go.

Equally detested by the Sunni ISIL are Shiite Muslims, Kurds, Christians and — if there are any left in Iraq or Syria — Jews. Sunni ISIL cannot even tolerate their own fellow Sunnis who don’t share their extremist hatred or subscribe to the same Shariah-inspired Islam they do.

ISIL’s solution for their inability to tolerate others is clear and simple: Kill them.

The so-called “take home” message here is that ISIL is far from alone. If anybody wants to know how things would go if the Muslim Brotherhood again ruled Egypt, if Hezbollah gained complete control of Lebanon, if al-Qaida toppled the royal family in Saudi Arabia, if Hamas ever gained the upper hand in Israel, just examine the track record of ISIL in Iraq and Syria.

In other words, just ask the Yazidi. Those who survive their present peril, we believe, will be only too willing to tell their stories.

Yet another valuable lesson — and perhaps a ray of hope — is provided by how the West, particularly the US, is reacting to the mountaintop siege in Iraq.

It might well be correctly and convincingly argued that the Obama administration’s role in the horrific breakdown of Syria has been unfocused and exceedingly hesitant, as many critics (recently including likely 2016 Democratic presidential candidate Hillary Clinton) have charged.

Recent American actions in Kurdistan, however, are hinting that at least some of those lessons have been learned. Food and water drops to the stranded Yazidi, not to mention airstrikes against the besieging ISIL, suggest that the US is beginning to put its money where its mouth is.

We are not suggesting that the US role in Iraq should revert to the titanic levels of a few years ago — nor that the American ground war strategy was the right one — but we do believe that President Obama is right to engage in the current actions against ISIL and that he should be encouraged, we hope, in a bipartisan way.

What is taking place in Iraq at this moment is but one theater in a much larger conflict, one involving many countries, ethnic groups and religions. It will be surely be a long and bloody confrontation, but it’s extremely important that the West, and the US in particular, commit to it with strength and clarity.

The stakes are as high as they can be, reminiscent of the great 20th-century struggles between freedom and totalitarianism. This is nothing less than civilization versus barbarism. Genocide should be an idea strictly of historical interest. On this, the eve of the 100th anniversary of the Armenan genocide, let not Yazidi join the terrible list.

Copyright © 2014 by the Intermountain Jewish News


IJN e-Edition

This is only a taste! Get full access to the IJN via our e-Edition, only $14.04 for IJN Print subscribers.

E-Edition subscribers get access to a complete digital replica of the IJN, which includes all special sections.

Get the IJN's free newsletter!

Shabbat Times

JTA News

Despite Jewish security concerns, new kosher supermarket opens in Berlin

Marcy Oster The store’s owners are optimistic for its success, despite security concerns and the recent European Union decision to require relabeling of products made in the West Bank and Golan Heights, ... [Link]

Anne Frank’s diary to be published online in challenge to copyright

Julie Wiener Plans to publish Anne Frank’s diary online in January are challenges to the foundation that owns the rights to the book and is seeking to extend its copyright by naming her father, Otto, a co-au... [Link]

Meet Oren Hazan, Israel’s most scandalous lawmaker

Ben Sales Allegations against the freshman lawmaker have run the gamut from drugs to sex to bigotry. ... [Link]

How the Chabad rebbe helped create food stamps, and other Jewish Medal of Freedom stories

Ron Kampeas While Rabbi Menachem Mendel Schneerson didn’t receive any credit at the Presidential Medal of Freedom ceremony, Judaism got plenty of love. ... [Link]

For Jimmy Carter’s chief of staff, being Jewish was a family secret

Gabrielle Birkner For Kathleen Jordan, finishing the memoir of her late father, Hamilton Jordan, was a labor of love, a way to process her grief and an exercise in embracing her own Southern identity. ... [Link]

Met Council’s Rapfogel released to minimum-security prison with view of Central Park

Julie Wiener For 10 days Rapfogel will be restricted to a minimum-security facility across the street from Central Park, then will be allowed to leave during the day to go to work. ... [Link]

Bishops in England and Wales call for Vatican to revise liturgy concerning Jews

Julie Wiener The chairman of the bishops’ Committee for Catholic-Jewish Relations said the current wording of the prayer has caused “great confusion and upset in the Jewish community.” ... [Link]

Op-Ed: Why Conservative Judaism should accept patrilineal Jews

Uriel Heilman When a couple with a patrilineal Jewish partner gets married, do we want a Conservative rabbi standing with them under the huppah, a rabbi from a more liberal movement or no rabbi at all? asks the exe... [Link]

Intermountain Jewish News • 1177 Grant Street • Denver, CO 80203 • 303 861 2234 • FAX 303 832 6942 • •