Intermountain Jewish News

Banner
Thursday,
Sep 03rd

Layers of horror

E-mail Print PDF

Murder of Israeli teens, immolation of a Palestinian teen, Hamas rockets. A time for war — and a wakeup call.

I.

Sadly enough, the murder, apparently by Jews, of a Palestinian boy, 16 — it is apparently necessary to state — is ethically repugnant and politically stupid, both in the extreme. This, even if the Palestinian boy were not burned to death.

It becomes necessary to state corollaries:

• Jewish education in Israel, the amazing efflorescence in Torah study there notwithstanding, is missing something basic, something prior to ritual and intellection, namely, ethics; as in, thou shalt not kill.

• Holocaust education in Israel, at least in some circles, is woefully inadequate. The burning of a human being is something that every Israeli should know about and viscerally recoil from — not that the violation of thou shalt not kill in any form is less horrendous.

• The death penalty in Israel for terrorists, regardless of ethnicity, must be seriously examined. The release of murderers from prison only spurs more murders, including, it now seems, by Jews.

• The moral high ground in Israel, occupied for weeks courtesy of Palestinian kidnappers and murderers of Israeli teens, is, in its own way, repugnant and obtuse — repugnant, because there is no value in Jews gaining sympathy and support once again for being the pitied victim; and obtuse, because no one outside Israel cares whether the country occupies the moral high ground or not.

• The reality in Israel — the miraculous realization of Jewish economic, intellectual, political and social ideals, but also the home of a deep alienation, a drastic ignorance of Jewish moral and ethical values — must be faced. Israel needs more than unthinking support from the Diaspora, symbolized by the ridiculously idealized image of Israel pushed by Birthright. Friends do not let friends drive drunk.

II.

Hardly the most important matter at this moment, but necessary by way of perspective, is the matter of chronology.

In the aftermath of three murdered Israeli teens, of one murdered Palestinian teen, and of Hamas’ launch of still another war against Israel, perspective is imperative. We have been so overwhelmed with one layer of horror after another that chronology is imperative to be able to distinguish between seemingly related events. And so:

The rocket attacks on Gaza began before the discovery of the body of a murdered Palestinian boy. The rocket attacks began weeks earlier, before the kidnapping of three Israeli boys, last June 12, became known. The rocket attacks were calculated acts of war, intentional acts of hatred.

Not: Hamas rockets as revenge for an Israeli murder.

Not: Cause-and-effect.

It’s anyone’s guess why Hamas timed its new war close to the kidnapping of the three Israeli boys. Was this an attempt to engender support for the West Bank supporters of Hamas? Was this an attempt to diminish understanding for Israel’s search for the three boys? Is there any rationality at all amongst the leaders of Hamas, sworn to Israel’s destruction, long accustomed to regard their own suffering as secondary to their hatred for Israel?

Whatever — the new Hamas war was not a response to the murder of the Palestinian boy, not a stage in a “cycle of violence,” as if there were any logic, even a perverted logic of violence and revenge, to the attacks on Israel by Hamas. These attacks need no logic. In 2005, Israel withdrew from every square inch of the land of Gaza that Hamas occupies and rules — and still the attacks continue. If Israel and the Palestinian Authority reached an agreement for Palestinian independence, these attacks would continue.

They are acts of war and hatred. Nothing else.

One targeted Israeli assassination of a Hamas leader brings another bravado-animated Hamas leader to the fore. His fate, often as not, is sealed in the same way. No matter — the hatred continues. It knows no logic. That is depressing because irrational hatred knows no productive counterproposal. But recognition of the irrationality of Hamas’ hatred for Israel would be liberating. Acknowledgement that only Hamas can save itself from itself would save the likes of naifs John Kerry and others from worsening the Israel-Palestinian conflict by raising wholly unrealistic expectations of a comprehensive solution.

Not every problem has a solution; not, at least, a solution from without. A change of heart, a radical excision of anti-Semitism from the manifesto of Hamas, can only come from within.

Meanwhile, Jews and Israelis are left with their own internal work to do — Jewish boys apparently  burning a Palestinian boy to death! It is more than a disgrace. It is a wakeup call.

Copyright © 2014 by the Intermountain Jewish News

 

IJN e-Edition

This is only a taste! Get full access to the IJN via our e-Edition, only $14.04 for IJN Print subscribers.

E-Edition subscribers get access to a complete digital replica of the IJN, which includes all special sections.

Get the IJN's free newsletter!

Cast Your Vote

Should the US support the nuclear deal negotiated between the P5+1 and Iran?
 

Shabbat Times

JTA News

Zero-tolerance policy on anti-Semitism, Belgian PM vows

Cnaan Liphshiz Security for Jews in Antwerp, where some 18,000 Jews live, was a prominent issue on the agenda during Prime Minister Charles Michel’s visit. ... [Link]

Norwegian politician compares smoking bans to Nazi persecution of Jews

Julie Wiener “This is legally enforced discrimination. Jews were also already being persecuted from 1933,” said Geir Finne, leader of Norway’s Coastal Party. ... [Link]

J Street U’s new Muslim president says she’s ‘culturally Jewish’

Andrew Tobin Amna Farooqi, a senior at the University of Maryland, is a critic of Benjamin Netanyahu, but reads David Ben-Gurion. ... [Link]

Kerry: U.S. will use ‘all tools’ to confront Iranian destabilization

Ron Kampeas Kerry says he outlined security plans for the region in letter to Congress. ... [Link]

It’s Jew vs. Jew (and rabbi vs. rabbi) in fight over Lithuanian site

Cnaan Liphshiz Lithuania’s chief rabbi has been fired, a British rabbinic group is being accused of corruption and a $25 million renovation plan is at stake in a dispute over the Jewish cemetery where the Viln... [Link]

Netanyahu orders reexamination of IDF open-fire orders on rock throwers

Marcy Oster The order came during a discussion in the Prime Minister’s Office of the security situation in Jerusalem and along the main highway into the city, as well as the West Bank. ... [Link]

Israel’s real-life national cop drama, explained

Andrew Tobin 40 percent of the Israel police’s top brass have been forced out in recent years over corruption or sexual harassment scandals. Now, there may be a new sheriff in town, but he has a history of h... [Link]

Who’s behind Broadway’s hip-hop hit ‘Hamilton’? Jewish biographer Ron Chernow

Lisa Keys ‘The last thing I would have expected,’ admits the award-winning Jewish biographer, who served as a historical consultant for Lin-Manuel Miranda’s unprecedented smash. ... [Link]

Intermountain Jewish News • 1177 Grant Street • Denver, CO 80203 • 303 861 2234 • FAX 303 832 6942
email@ijn.com • larry@ijn.com • lori@ijn.com