Intermountain Jewish News

Apr 16th

Calling a critique of Kerry ‘personal’ is a slippery slope

E-mail Print PDF

It is certainly true that to make nasty remarks about, let alone threats against, Sec. of State John Kerry is beyond the pale and, to boot, counerproductive. That said, it also true that it becomes easy to squelch debate about Kerry’s Israel-Palestinian initiative by calling critiques of his policies “personal.”

To be sure, it is not yet known precisely what his policies are. But a lot has been leaked, and, beyond that, since when is it is the role of a third country to dictate to Israel or to the Palestinians what the terms of an agreement between them ought to be? Who, after all, has to live with the agreement? Who suffers if it fails? Not the American secretary of state.

If, for example, John Kerry says that boycotts of Israel will multiply if his current peace effort fails, it is not a personal attack to say that he is blaming Israel in advance for the failure of the talks. It is not a personal attack to say that the fact that Kerry himself opposes boycotts of Israel, and has always opposed boycotts of Israel, is irrelevant to his raising the subject in advance of the talks’ conclusion. If Economy Minister Naftali Bennett says that Kerry has “amplified” the boycott movement, this is not a personal attack. It is a response to remarks that Kerry chose to make.

Read related news coverage, "Obama enlists Jews to counter attacks on Kerry"

The fault here is on both sides: on the side of a Knesset Member, for comparing Kerry to Nebuchadnezzar, which surely qualifies as a personal attack; and on the side of Kerry, for speaking in a way that invites blame on Israel. To critique either side is not a personal attack.

It is a slippery slope to make a big deal out of personal attacks — one would think that a person in the august position of secretary of state could take them — because free speech, on all sides, about the fate of nations is critical to the ultimate success of a peace effort.

One can only wonder: Did the offensive attack that Kerry is over his head in regard to Israel’s security elicit formal responses from the State Dept. (and other American officials) because the attack, in fact, cuts too close to the truth for comfort?

Copyright © 2104 by the Intermountain Jewish News

Last Updated ( Thursday, 13 February 2014 14:42 )  

Get the IJN's free newsletter!

Cast Your Vote

Should recognition of Israel as a Jewish state be a deal breaker?

Shabbat Times

JTA News

Palestinian rioters attack IDF outpost in Hebron

Marcy Oster Dozens of Palestinians attacked an Israel Defense Forces outpost in Hebron. ... [Link]

Flyers call on Ukrainian Jews to register with pro-Russian separatists

Cnaan Liphshiz Pro-Russian separatists from Donetsk in eastern Ukraine denied any involvement in the circulation of flyers calling on Jews to register with separatists and pay special taxes. ... [Link]

Paris court dismisses racial hatred charge against Bob Dylan

Marcy Oster A civil court in Paris dismissed a case of incitement to hatred against American singer Bob Dylan for remarks he made in an interview with Rolling Stone Magazine. ... [Link]

Passover supplies arrive in Nepal in time for massive seder

Marcy Oster A large shipment of Passover supplies arrived in Kathmandu just in time for seder. ... [Link]

Hebron shooting victim laid to rest amid condemnations

Marcy Oster Hundreds attended the funeral for Israel Police Chief Superintendent Baruch Mizrahi, who was killed near Hebron while on his way to a Passover seder with his family. ... [Link]

Suspected Kansas City JCC shooter charged with murder in state court

Marcy Oster The suspect in the shootings of three people at two Jewish institutions in suburban Kansas City was charged in state court. ... [Link]

State Dept. voices support for peace talks as negotiators postpone meeting

Marcy Oster Israeli and Palestinian peace negotiators postponed a scheduled meeting, as the U.S. State Department reiterated its support for the talks. ... [Link]

Temple Mount closed to Jewish visitors following Arab rioting

Marcy Oster The Temple Mount was closed to Jewish visitors on the second day of Passover following rioting at the site by dozens of Arab youth. ... [Link]

Intermountain Jewish News • 1177 Grant Street • Denver, CO 80203 • 303 861 2234 • FAX 303 832 6942 • •