Intermountain Jewish News

Jul 22nd

Calling a critique of Kerry ‘personal’ is a slippery slope

E-mail Print PDF

It is certainly true that to make nasty remarks about, let alone threats against, Sec. of State John Kerry is beyond the pale and, to boot, counerproductive. That said, it also true that it becomes easy to squelch debate about Kerry’s Israel-Palestinian initiative by calling critiques of his policies “personal.”

To be sure, it is not yet known precisely what his policies are. But a lot has been leaked, and, beyond that, since when is it is the role of a third country to dictate to Israel or to the Palestinians what the terms of an agreement between them ought to be? Who, after all, has to live with the agreement? Who suffers if it fails? Not the American secretary of state.

If, for example, John Kerry says that boycotts of Israel will multiply if his current peace effort fails, it is not a personal attack to say that he is blaming Israel in advance for the failure of the talks. It is not a personal attack to say that the fact that Kerry himself opposes boycotts of Israel, and has always opposed boycotts of Israel, is irrelevant to his raising the subject in advance of the talks’ conclusion. If Economy Minister Naftali Bennett says that Kerry has “amplified” the boycott movement, this is not a personal attack. It is a response to remarks that Kerry chose to make.

Read related news coverage, "Obama enlists Jews to counter attacks on Kerry"

The fault here is on both sides: on the side of a Knesset Member, for comparing Kerry to Nebuchadnezzar, which surely qualifies as a personal attack; and on the side of Kerry, for speaking in a way that invites blame on Israel. To critique either side is not a personal attack.

It is a slippery slope to make a big deal out of personal attacks — one would think that a person in the august position of secretary of state could take them — because free speech, on all sides, about the fate of nations is critical to the ultimate success of a peace effort.

One can only wonder: Did the offensive attack that Kerry is over his head in regard to Israel’s security elicit formal responses from the State Dept. (and other American officials) because the attack, in fact, cuts too close to the truth for comfort?

Copyright © 2104 by the Intermountain Jewish News

Last Updated ( Thursday, 13 February 2014 14:42 )  

IJN e-Edition

This is only a taste! Get full access to the IJN via our e-Edition, only $14.04 for IJN Print subscribers.

E-Edition subscribers get access to a complete digital replica of the IJN, which includes all special sections.

Get the IJN's free newsletter!

Shabbat Times

JTA News

Iran talks extended, but uranium enrichment remains stumbling block

Ron Kampeas Tehran and the major powers have agreed to keep talking, but progress remains elusive on the core issue of Iranian centrifuges. ... [Link]

Protesters arrested after ‘die-in’ at Friends of IDF office

Miriam Moster Nine protesters against Israel’s Gaza operation were arrested inside the Manhattan offices of the Friends of the Israel Defense Forces. ... [Link]

For two Americans, service to Israel ends in tragedy

Daniel Treiman Sean Carmeli and Max Steinberg, young immigrants to Israel, lost their lives in Gaza warfare. ... [Link]

Emergency transfer denied in kosher prison food case

Anthony Weiss A federal judge rejected a request by a Venezuelan Jewish detainee for an emergency transfer from an Alabama prison over complaints that it was not providing kosher meals. ... [Link]

Israeli soldier killed in Gaza firefight

Marcy Oster An Israeli soldier was killed in a “fire exchange” in Gaza, the Israel Defense Forces announced. ... [Link]

Rockets discovered at second U.N. school in Gaza

Marcy Oster Rockets were discovered in a second United Nations school in Gaza. ... [Link]

J Street explains pullout from Boston pro-Israel rally

Ron Kampeas J Street withdrew from a pro-Israel rally in Boston because it did not feel the rally would address all the group’s concerns. ... [Link]

Amid France synagogue attacks, support for Jewish self-defense group on the rise

Cnaan Liphshiz France’s Jewish Defense League, a controversial group with a history of vigilantism, is enjoying growing support amid fears that police cannot protect Jewish institutions. ... [Link]

Intermountain Jewish News • 1177 Grant Street • Denver, CO 80203 • 303 861 2234 • FAX 303 832 6942 • •