Intermountain Jewish News

Nov 29th

A ‘continguous’ Palestinian state: that is, a racist one

E-mail Print PDF

Maybe it’s a good idea, maybe it’s a bad idea, for Israel to build new housing in “E1,” an area between currently settled parts of Jerusalem and the Jerusalem suburb of Maale Adumim. But one thing such housing is not: damage to a potential Palestinian state on the West Bank. Think carefully about that claim, and it’s actually racist.

The Palestinian claim, parroted by commentators around the world so naturally, so automatically, so mellifluously, that it has assumed the mantle of truth, is that a Palestinian state with Jewish settlements is not a viable state. It is not “continuous,” and if it is not continuous, it is not real. It is a series of “Bantustans.” It is a joke. It is evidence of bad faith on the part of Israel. It is a actually a cynical attempt by Israel to preclude a Palestinian state. That is the claim.

Denver is interrupted by Glendale. Obversely, put it this way: Glendale is surrounded by Denver. Does this geographical and governmental disjunction disrupt Denver? No. Does it disrupt Glendale? No. It is unusual, but not harmful. In fact, it has its charm.

A more biting example: Think Dick’s Sporting Goods Park on Quebec St. in the small municipality of Commerce City. Think Denver south of Colfax and Quebec. Sandwiched in between them is the lovely Park Hill neighborhood. Park Hill is preponderantly a black neighborhood. Is Park Hill “cut off” from the rest of Denver by virtue of being “surrounded” by Commerce City and East Denver? Is Park Hill discriminated against? No. Is Park Hill unviable, by virtue of its geographical- ethnic “isolation” and “discontiguity”? No.

Yet, Palestinians would have us believe that a Palestinian state must be ethnically monochromatic, empty of Jews and geographically pure, smooth, uniform, “contiguous”:  strictly Palestinian Arab. That is, racist. No Jews, and no Jewish settlements, allowed.

Continuity might be a reasonable concept in a huge land mass and a correspondingly huge territory like Saudi Arabia or the United States. Distances are vast. It might be impractical to extend sovereignty in pieces over a huge land mass.

But in an extremely small area — the land mass between the Jordan River and the Mediterranean Sea, for example; or in metropolitan Denver, for example — it is almost inevitable that diverse settlements, neighborhoods, municipalities and ethnic enslaves will emerge. It’s no big deal. And it shouldn’t be a big deal in the tiny territory between the River and the Sea.

But, you say, why must Israel build there? Israel is building. The Palestinians are building. Both are building. Every day. Literally. Cheek by jowl. Literally. That’s much of life on this small land mass. If two peoples are to get along there, they’ll have to get along right next to each other. That’s the reality. Two rapidly growing populations in a very small space.

To subdivide it out — to extract 1.5 million Arabs from within Israel’s borders; or to extract hundreds of thousands of settlers from the West Bank — is: Impractical. Unnecessary. Racist.

Copyright © 2012 by the Intermountain Jewish News

Last Updated ( Wednesday, 12 December 2012 00:45 )  

IJN e-Edition

This is only a taste! Get full access to the IJN via our e-Edition, only $14.04 for IJN Print subscribers.

E-Edition subscribers get access to a complete digital replica of the IJN, which includes all special sections.

Get the IJN's free newsletter!

Shabbat Times

JTA News

Op-Ed: On #GivingTuesday, time to turn philanthropic thinking on its head

Joelle Asaro Berman Build a Jewish philanthropic culture focused on the interests of the giver and the donations will follow, two nonprofit execs write. ... [Link]

Netanyahu suspends contact with EU on peace process

Marcy Oster The order comes in the wake of the European Union’s decision to approve special labeling for Israeli products made in the West Bank and Golan Heights. ... [Link]

South African mohel banned for life for botching bris

Marcy Oster The baby’s penis was partially amputated and suffered irreversible damage during the circumcision. ... [Link]

Report: Palestinian teen shot dead in clashes with Israeli forces

Marcy Oster Palestinian rioters threw firebombs at Israeli forces in eastern Jerusalem, who fired at the rioters’ lower extremities after feeling that their lives were in danger, Israel Police said. ... [Link]

Rio Jews, evangelicals rally for peace in Israel

Marcy Oster The estimated 1,500 participants along the beach carried Israel signs, wore Israel shirts and sang the national anthems of Israel and Brazil. ... [Link]

At Hanukkah, how do we kindle the lights within ourselves?

mbrodsky “The life breath (the soul) of a human is the lamp of God,” it says in the Book of Proverbs. ... [Link]

On Hanukkah, just let the lights go out

Lisa Keys Celebrating the Festival of Lights is typically a communal activity — but a writer finds a deeper meaning in quiet contemplation of the menorah. ... [Link]

Thousands of Arab-Israelis protest ban on Islamic Movement

Marcy Oster Arab-Israeli Knesset lawmakers attended the rally backing a group that Israel accuses of incitement and links to terrorism. ... [Link]

Intermountain Jewish News • 1177 Grant Street • Denver, CO 80203 • 303 861 2234 • FAX 303 832 6942 • •