Intermountain Jewish News

Banner
Tuesday,
Feb 09th

Agreement — and illusion — on Iran?

E-mail Print PDF

At their final presidential debate, Pres. Obama and Gov. Romney agreed to a large extent on their approach to Iran’s nuclear pursuit: Stop Iran, but stop it via sanctions; and only if those fail, consider more drastic options.

The question is, what is the definition of the “failure” of sanctions? Both candidates seem to believe that the sanctions cannot fail. Both candidates seem to believe that the tougher the sanctions, the greater the chance that Iran will stop its nuclear pursuit. Both candidates cite the strong effects of the sanctions on Iran’s economy.

Both candidates place their hope in rationality. Both seem to believe that a country will balance the suffering imposed by sanctions against the potential gains afforded by being a nuclear power, and decide to forgo the economic pain when it gets unbearable.

Maybe that’s a great strategy. Maybe that’s a grand illusion. The problem is that neither candidate seems to entertain the possibility that it is an illusion. The risk in the candidates’ American, pragmatic, rational, culture-bound approach is that it could blind them to the fact Iran may never forgo its nuclear pursuit, no matter what. Don’t forget, even internal opponents of the Iran regime are reportedly gung ho about Iran’s nuclear pursuit. There is an internal dispute in Iran about Islamic dictatorship, not about Iran’s nuclear program.

There is another potential illusion here, namely, that at all times the US, due to its own intelligence and to Israel’s and others’, will always know the precise stage of Iran’s nuclear development. Maybe. But it would seem judicious to err on the side of caution; that is, not to wait until the last minute before acting.

Not to mention, the difficulty in militarily striking Iran’s nuclear facilities only increases as time goes by. The Iranians are not sitting tight on their defenses. They’re improving them, as well as their weapons delivery capability.

All of the difficulties with the candidates’ positions on Iran notwithstanding, it is undeniable that both articulate the threat posed by Iran forcefully. This is, no doubt, a result of an even more forceful Israeli policy of making clear (a) Iran’s existential threat to Israel; (b) Israel’s willingness to act on that threat; (c) Israel’s preference for the US to act on that threat; and (d) Israel’s success in conveying that a nuclear Iran would trigger a Middle East nuclear arms race. Israel’s repeated statement of the dire nature of the Iranian threat has, at the very least, caused the president of the US and his challenger to state for the record that Iran is a threat to American national security, not just Israeli national security. That is a signal achievement for Israel. No doubt, it will cause Israel to be even more forceful — more threatening to Iran — in the future, should the sanctions fail.

Copyright © 2012 by the Intermountain Jewish News

Last Updated ( Thursday, 25 October 2012 02:07 )  

IJN e-Edition

This is only a taste! Get full access to the IJN via our e-Edition, only $14.04 for IJN Print subscribers.

E-Edition subscribers get access to a complete digital replica of the IJN, which includes all special sections.

Get the IJN's free newsletter!

Cast Your Vote

Would you vote for Bernie Sanders?
 

Shabbat Times

JTA News

Israeli jogger stabbed in West Bank

Marcy Oster Earlier in the day, a 16-year-old Palestinian girl was arrested in Jerusalem after attempting to stab Israeli police officers. ... [Link]

U of Illinois Chabad menorah vandalized for 3rd time within a year

Marcy Oster A surveillance video showed a man and a woman breaking an arm off the 9-foot menorah; the woman was later arrested. ... [Link]

Founder of Orthodox muckraker blog Failed Messiah sells – but did he sell out?

Uriel Heilman Why is Shmarya Rosenberg, whose mission was to expose secrets, refusing to disclose the buyers of his controversial blog? ... [Link]

Sanders wins Dixville Notch, first vote in New Hampshire’s primary

Marcy Oster The town has nine registered voters, and the four Democrats went for the Jewish senator from neighboring Vermont. Among the Republicans, Ohio Gov. John Kasich edged Donald Trump, 3-2. ... [Link]

Dutch deputy PM: Anti-Semitic abuse keeps me off social media

Cnaan Liphshiz Lodewijk Asscher, who has Jewish ancestors, in a Facebook post lists the handles of several Twitter users who used anti-Semitic language against him. ... [Link]

Sheldon Adelson’s attorney: Billionaire does not own Israel Hayom daily newspaper

Marcy Oster Adelson has been cited frequently in media reports as the right-wing newspaper’s owner, including by JTA. ... [Link]

Bloomberg confirms he is considering 2016 presidential run

Marcy Oster The ex-New York mayor criticized the quality of the debate in the presidential race and said he was “looking into all options” when asked about entering the race. ... [Link]

Austrian prosecutors: Mauthausen Holocaust survivors may be called criminals

Cnaan Liphshiz The president of Vienna’s Jewish community said the failure to indict the authors of a magazine article reaffirmed Nazi logic. ... [Link]

Intermountain Jewish News • 1177 Grant Street • Denver, CO 80203 • 303 861 2234 • FAX 303 832 6942
email@ijn.com • larry@ijn.com • lori@ijn.com