Intermountain Jewish News

Sep 02nd
Home Columns View from Denver Silence in the Haggadah and beyond

Silence in the Haggadah and beyond

E-mail Print PDF


“. . . a time to be silent and a time to speak.” — Ecclesiastes 3:7

HAGADDAH means “telling” and Passover, of course, is the holiday of retelling the exodus from Egypt — the holiday of conversation, of questions and answers, of debates and inquiry. However, in one small corner of the Haggadah silence reigns. The fourth son in the Haggadah does not know how to ask a question. “You open up for him,” says the Haggadah. You start the conversation, since the fourth son is silent.

Sometimes, however, silence is the conversation.

This week’s Torah portion begins, “After the death of the two sons of Aaron . . . ” (Lev. 16:1). Earlier, the Torah records that these two sons, “Nadav and Avihu, each took his fire pan . . . and brought before the    L-rd an an alien fire . . . A fire came forth from before the L-rd and consumed them, and they died . . . And Moses said to Aaron: Of this did the L-rd speak, saying, I will be sanctified through those who are nearest Me . . . and Aaron was silent” (Lev. 10:1-3).

Aaron loses two sons, and he’s silent?

Rashi says: Aaron was rewarded for his silence in that G-d delivered to him alone [not also to Moses] the law of intoxicants (Lev. 8-11).

Nachmanides: Aaron stopped weeping after he heard Moses’ words of comfort.

Seforno: Aaron was comforted in that his sons sanctified G-d’s name.

Other possibilities: Aaron was too angry, or too crushed, or too surprised, or too baffled to utter a word.

Or, we might translate Aaron’s silence as “And Aaron held his peace.”

Which is exactly what the Jewish mourner sitting shiva — the person one of whose seven closest relatives dies — has the right to do. A visitor to a “shiva house” must remain perfectly silent until the mourner initiates a conversation, which he is not required to do; and, indeed, some never do. Silence is the conversation.

“Dedication of the book to my wife, Atarah, is a pale indication of my profound, all-consuming indebtedness to her. Any attempt to articulate it . . . would inevitably ring hollow, but inasmuch as she is attuned to my silences she will understand every nuance and hear every resonance. . . . ” — Isadore Twersky, preface to Introduction to the Code of Maimonides

“Only to G-d is my soul silent.” — Psalms 62:2

SILENCE can be pragmatic: “I have found nothing better for the body than silence.” — Ethics of the Fathers, Pirkei Avot 1:17

Some take this to mean that one should not speak about “bodily” matters — the material, the mundane, the physical, the great steak one had last night, the beautiful dress one saw. Rather, let the mouth be silent about the body and instead soar with talk about prayer and purity and ethics.

I believe that Pirkei Avot can be taken literally. In a moment of great stress, anger or argument, it is the body itself that is preserved by cooling down or by not taking the bait — by being silent, tempting as it might be to answer, or to lash out.

“Rabbi Akiva said . . . A protective fence for wisdom is silence.” — Pirkei Avot 3:17

“A word is worth a sela, but silence is worth two.” — Megillah 18a

The medieval sage, Rabbi Yehuda the Pious, said:

“When I speak, I have reason to regret. But when I am silent, I have nothing to regret. Before I speak, I am master over my words; once the words leave my mouth, they rule over me.”

You don’t have to defend what you didn’t say. — Rabbi Hillel Goldberg

TWO ironies of silence: In Speech v. Silence, Mr. Speech and Mr. Silence appear before the court. First, Mr. Speech defends speech as essential to human community, commerce and friendship. Then Mr. Silence begins to defend silence. Mr. Speech gets up and slaps Mr. Silence across the face. The judge asks, what was that for? Mr. Speech replies: He is going to defend his with mine? — The Ways of the Righteous (The Gate of Silence)

The quintessential Jewish prayer is the “Silent Prayer,” the Shemoneh Esrei or Amidah. Walk into a synagogue when it is being recited and you can hear pin drop or, at most, the turning of pages. Silence is the apex of prayer. However, one does not discharge one’s obligation in reciting the Shemoneh Esrei unless one articulates the words loud enough for oneself to hear them — but not so loud that anyone else can hear them.

The Silent Prayer is silent, and not silent.

The Hebrew language has many words for silence. One we have not yet referenced is used in the book of Esther.

Mordechai addresses Esther after Haman has convinced King Ahasuerus to sanction genocide against the Jewish people. “Because if you will be silent at this time,” Mordechai warns Esther, “then relief and deliverance will come from somewhere else, and you and your father’s house will perish . . . ” (4:14).

As Rabbi David Fohrman points out, the Hebrew word for silence used by Mordechai denotes deafness. Mordechai is saying to Esther, “If you make yourself deaf, as if you do not know what is going on . . . ”

Silence, in other words, is not just passive. It can be active, making oneself deaf to what what one prefers to avoid.

Silence can be active in another way. People fast on Yom Kippur. “Fast” means not to eat food. Judaism has a related, if rarer, practice: a speech fast. Not to speak for a designated time. A ta’anit dibbur, a speech fast, is not only a protective fence for wisdom, but a spur to repentance.

THE Jewish tradition has still another way of being silent. It is to quote selectively.

For example, the medieval Hebrew Jewish legal scholar, referred to as Semag, often quotes Maimonides’ legal code. Semag will quote Maimonides verbatim — then suddenly omit a phrase. This changes Maimonides’ meaning. The law, as formulated by Maimonides, comes out different by virtue of Semag’s omission. In effect, Semag’s renders Maimonides silent on an issue about which Maimonides himself spoke.

American tradition has its own take on silence. Under the Fifth Amendment to the US Constitution, an accused criminal has the right to remain silent. He may not be judged guilty on that account. The Jewish legal tradition, reflected in the Talmud, looks at things rather differently. It rules: “Silence is tantamount to confession [of the crime].”

In another context, the Talmud praises silence when one is insulted, but does not insult in return (Gitin 36b, Shabbos 88b).

Jewish secular tradition — or at least one exemplar of it — posits a tremendous capacity for interpreting silence. A. B. Yehoshua wrote a novel, Mr. Mani, which is a series of dialogues. In each dialogue, however, only one side is quoted. The entire novel records the words of only one of two speakers. The reader is left to imagine the other side of the dialogue.

“THERE are times of silence and times of speech. When it is a time of preparation to receive Divine influence, all is silent and listens. When the time comes that each entity can influence the next, then speech begins. One needs to prepare himself for the attribute of silence, in order to hear the heavenly voice, and G-d’s word will be upon him.” — Rabbi Abraham Y. Kuk, Orot Hakodesh (vol. 1, p. 110)

“Silence comes from the depths of the soul and from emotions that lie beyond human speech. When the deep person remains silent, worlds are being formed, songs are composed in the heights of sanctity, and a great strength elevates one’s whole being.” — R. Kuk, ibid. (vol. 3, p. 274)

“It would be disastrous for one to be unable to remain silent and have to speak at a time when the inner light deemed it a time for silence. This rebellion against the kingdom of silence destroys worlds. Afterward, one would have to rebuild them from scratch, and so the wise remain silent at such times.” — R. Kuk, ibid. (p. 275)

“To You [G-d], silence is praise.” — Psalms 65:2

Copyright © 2014 by the Intermountain Jewish News

Last Updated ( Friday, 11 April 2014 02:57 )  

IJN e-Edition

This is only a taste! Get full access to the IJN via our e-Edition, only $14.04 for IJN Print subscribers.

E-Edition subscribers get access to a complete digital replica of the IJN, which includes all special sections.

Get the IJN's free newsletter!

Shabbat Times

JTA News

Blockers and tacklers: Jewish gridders gearing up for NFL campaign

mbrodsky Blocking brothers and fullback who hasn’t had a carry in four seasons are among the Jewish players on NFL rosters as the league kicks off this week. ... [Link]

Report: SodaStream mulling departure from West Bank plant

Marcy Oster The Israeli firm SodaStream, which has been a target of the Boycott, Divestment and Sanctions movement, is considering closing its West Bank factory. ... [Link]

Canadian Nazi Party founder running for Ontario township post

Marcy Oster The founder of the Canadian Nazi Party, John Beattie, is running for deputy head of the town council in an Ontario community. ... [Link]

Foreign Affairs Committee’s Royce and Engel to visit Israel

Marcy Oster Reps. Ed Royce and Eliot Engel of the House Foreign Affairs Committee will visit Israel this week. ... [Link]

Turkish Jews can stay mum on Israel’s Gaza op, Turkish Jewish intellectuals say

Marcy Oster Jewish citizens of Turkey are under no obligation to comment on Israel’s operation in Gaza, a group of Jewish intellectuals in Turkey said in an open letter. ... [Link]

U.S. calls on Israel to reverse land appropriation

Marcy Oster The United States called on Israel to cancel the government appropriation of West Bank land in the Etzion bloc, while Israeli ministers praised and panned the decision. ... [Link]

Artists in Brazilian exhibition protest Israeli funding

Marcy Oster Most of the artists participating in a major Brazilian art event protested funding for the show from the Israeli government. ... [Link]

Thousands rally against escalating anti-Semitism in Britain

Marcy Oster Thousands of people gathered for a rally in central London to protest the rise in anti-Semitism in Britain. ... [Link]

Intermountain Jewish News • 1177 Grant Street • Denver, CO 80203 • 303 861 2234 • FAX 303 832 6942 • •