Intermountain Jewish News

Banner
Thursday,
Dec 18th
Home Columns View from Denver Rosa Parks, ADL, kosher food

Rosa Parks, ADL, kosher food

E-mail Print PDF

WHAT exactly was wrong with the way Rosa Parks was treated?

Parks, of course, was the courageous lady who began the Montgomery, Alabama bus boycott in 1955, a seminal event — both symbolic and effective — in the history of the Civil Rights movement.

Before she refused to sit in the back of the bus, was Parks denied her money’s worth? No, she paid for her ride, and the bus took her where she wanted to go.

Was Parks charged more than other people, and discriminated in that way? No.

Was Parks given an inferior ride? No, she was on the same bus as the white riders. Her ride was just as good as theirs.

Was Parks not allowed to take the bus? Was she denied entrance or participation in the public transportation system? Again, no.

Exactly what, then, was missing when she was asked to sit in the back of the bus? Not money, not comfort, not participation — but dignity.

Now, Rosa Parks was arrested for refusing to give up her seat in the colored section for a white rider after the white section had filled up; but there is no doubt that her goal was to put an end to the practice of making blacks sit in the back of the bus, even if they had a seat, even if they were allowed full participation in the bus ride. The primary insult she suffered was in being degraded. It was a matter of dignity.

There is also no doubt that her treatment was incomparably worse than mine.

CALL me naive. A month or six weeks ago I received an invitation to the 100th anniversary event of the ADL. I was excited. One hundred years is a magnificent milestone. It is not easy to sustain anything for 100 years.

To those who say, “well, of course, the fight against anti-Semitism will always find institutional sustainability,” actually, not. Readers might be surprised to learn that 70 years ago in Denver, these were the smaller organizations: the federation, ADL and JFS. Larger than all of them put together was B’nai B’rith. Not so today. Organizations don’t just keep going, no matter how important their mission. So I really was impressed by the upcoming 100th anniversary of ADL.

Not to mention, its mission against bigotry and anti-Semitism is noble and necessary.

So I sent off a reservation.

I assumed the event was kosher.

The Men’s Event of the federation is kosher.

The Shalom Park dinner is kosher.

The AIPAC breakfast is kosher.

The JNF breakfast is kosher.

The JCC dinner is kosher.

Of course, the ADL 100th anniversary dinner would also be kosher. I didn’t even give it a second thought. The ADL is about dignity and inclusiveness.

I thought the community had settled this issue 25 years ago, and it required no further conversation. But the ADL event was not kosher.

I guess the issue does require further conversation. So, here goes.

DID the ADL ask me to pay more to get into its event? No, the cost was the same.

Would I be denied a meal of the same quality as anyone else at this dinner? No, a quality substitute would be provided.

Would I be denied participation? Again, no.

Exactly what, then, was missing?

Dignity.

To be sure, the indignity of segregation was incomparably worse. But as the ADL itself rightly reminds us, large affronts begin with smaller ones. For me to keep kosher at the ADL’s non-kosher dinner would mean being singled out on the basis of religion. I (and some others) would be forced to become Mr. Oddball.

SHELDON Steinhauser, the longtime director of the local ADL, told me that he is very grateful for the existence of a newspaper like the Intermountain Jewish News, even though he definitely does not agree with every editorial stance it takes. I am very grateful for the existence of the ADL, even though I don’t agree with every policy stance it takes.

Kashrut, however, does not seems to be a policy disagreement. When I am told by an ADL spokesman that a kosher meal is more expensive, and the organization must be cognizant of budgetary issues, this seems to confirm that we are not dealing with a policy issue here.

I find it inexplicable that an organization so sensitive to including  minorities is insensitive to a well known teaching of the Torah — kashrut — when it is the Torah that is the basis of the Jewish commitment to justice and sensitivity to minorities.

If not for pride in the Torah, the long Jewish tradition of standing up for the underdog would not exist. It is the Torah that bequeathed to Jews the idea of doing the right thing, even if there’s a price.

If I argue for the right of an Hispanic child born in America to get in-state tuition, this is a source of Jewish pride, even though my stance might cost me business.

If I report someone who is engaged in human trafficking, this is a source of Jewish pride, even though I might put myself in some danger.

If I pay more taxes in order to be in strict compliance with the law, this is a source of Jewish pride, even though there is a price.

If I regard 10% of my net income as simply not belonging to me, but as belonging to tzedakah, this is a source of Jewish pride, whatever the financial loss.

The source of all this Jewish pride is the Torah. And when I hear that a kosher meal is more expensive, my instinctive reaction is: I am proud to have to pay the price.

Jewish dignity can, and often does, mean paying a price. Why is this even controversial?

However, if the added expense of making a large dinner kosher would pose a genuine budgetary challenge, Jewish pride and dignity have an inexpensive, more inclusive alternative to a non-kosher dinner: Don’t have a dinner. Have a smaller, more modest desert reception. Or a breakfast.

Rosa Parks didn’t want to hurt Montgomery’s bus company. She wanted it to succeed, just so long as it provided her with dignity along the way. The dignity of a kosher dinner is the proud cost of doing Jewish business for AIPAC, Shalom Park, DAT, Allied Jewish Federation, JNF, Hillel, JCC, DJDS and many others — because it’s the right thing to do.

Copyright © 2013 by the Intermountain Jewish News

Last Updated ( Friday, 21 June 2013 08:06 )  

IJN e-Edition

This is only a taste! Get full access to the IJN via our e-Edition, only $14.04 for IJN Print subscribers.

E-Edition subscribers get access to a complete digital replica of the IJN, which includes all special sections.

Get the IJN's free newsletter!

Shabbat Times

JTA News

Suspected Kansas City JCC shooter found competent to stand trial

Marcy Oster Frazier Glenn Cross Jr. said as he left the courtroom, “I had a right and a duty to do what I did.” ... [Link]

Causing stir, prominent Conservative rabbi considers breaking intermarriage ban

Uriel Heilman Rabbi Wesley Gardenswartz of Temple Emanuel in Newton, Mass., proposed a new synagogue policy that would have him officiate at interfaith weddings for couples who commit to a “Covenant to Raise Jewi... [Link]

Mossad spy reached Hezbollah’s upper ranks, Arab media report

Ron Kampeas A Lebanese businessman arrested last week succeeded the slain operations chief Imad Mughniyeh, the reports say. ... [Link]

Despite menorah confiscations, women kindle lights at Western Wall

Marcy Oster Security guards said they were acting on orders from the Kotel rabbi, Women of the Wall said. ... [Link]

Swedish lawmaker: Jews must assimilate to become true Swedes

Marcy Oster Far-right lawmaker Bjorn Soder angered Jewish leaders with his call on Jews and other minorities “to adapt to the Swedish and assimilate in order to become Swedish.” ... [Link]

Near major oil spill, a solar field grows in Israel

Ben Sales In the southern region where the country’s largest ever oil spill befouled a 3.5 mile stretch of desert, Israel hopes to become a leader in renewable energy. ... [Link]

Rabbi Harold Schulweis, pathbreaking thinker and activist, dies at 89

Julie Wiener The Conservative rabbi’s influence extended well beyond his Los Angeles-area congregation. ... [Link]

U.S. will not support draft Palestinian state resolution as it stands

Ron Kampeas The Obama administration does not support a draft Palestinian statehood resolution submitted to the U.N. Security Council. ... [Link]

Intermountain Jewish News • 1177 Grant Street • Denver, CO 80203 • 303 861 2234 • FAX 303 832 6942
email@ijn.com • larry@ijn.com • lori@ijn.com